The Rev. Jordan Warntjes was unanimously elected by the congregation of St. Andrew Presbyterian Church in March 2026 to serve as our next Pastor and Head of Staff. He and his wife, Michelle, will begin their ministry in Iowa City this spring, with his first Sunday in worship scheduled for May 10, 2026.
Pastor Jordan comes to St. Andrew from New Hope Presbyterian Church in Castle Rock, Colorado, where he has served as Associate Pastor since 2017. In that role, he has helped lead worship, guide faith formation for all ages, and support the life of the congregation through pastoral care, discipleship, and collaborative leadership with staff and lay leaders. During a recent pastoral transition at New Hope, he also served as Temporary Head of Staff, providing stability and direction for the congregation during an important season of change.
He holds a Master of Divinity from Western Theological Seminary and a Bachelor’s degree in Church and Ministry Leadership from Trinity Christian College. Ordained as a Minister of Word and Sacrament in the PC(USA) in 2014, he has also been active in the work of the wider church through the Denver Presbytery, including service in leadership and mediation roles.
Jordan describes his calling as walking alongside people in the real questions and complexities of life, helping congregations grow in faith, deepen community, and engage the world with courage and compassion.